Discussion:
(AFS) ENT "These Are The Voyages" - no spoilers
(too old to reply)
Randall Raemon
2005-05-30 18:22:39 UTC
Permalink
This was the final episode of Enterprise. It's more a TNG episode,
than an ENT episode. Being broadcast back-to-back with "Terra Prime"
made the contrast between the two episodes a bit... jarring.

So far as things Vulcan in this episode, I found it out of character.
It didn't sit right then, and hasn't since. This last season of
Enterprise had developed Vulcan in a way that was consistent with
TOS Vulcan. And this last episode didn't seem to have that consistency.
--
Randall Raemon
shikahrsoho.com, email to rlr or to owner-vulcan-l

-----------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from the Vulcan-L list, send an email message
of "unsubscribe vulcan-l" to Vulcan-L-Request at shikahrsoho.com
Selek
2005-05-31 17:58:03 UTC
Permalink
"Randall Raemon" <rlr@[127.0.0.1]> wrote in message news:***@vulcan-l.shikahrsoho.com...
|
| This was the final episode of Enterprise. It's more a TNG episode,
| than an ENT episode. Being broadcast back-to-back with "Terra Prime"
| made the contrast between the two episodes a bit... jarring.
|
| So far as things Vulcan in this episode, I found it out of character.
| It didn't sit right then, and hasn't since. This last season of
| Enterprise had developed Vulcan in a way that was consistent with
| TOS Vulcan. And this last episode didn't seem to have that consistency.
|
| --
| Randall Raemon
| shikahrsoho.com, email to rlr or to owner-vulcan-l

As far as I am concerned, Terra Prime was the last episode of Enterprise.
The other was merely a TNG episode that had nothing to do with Enterprise
whatsoever. I was very disappointed in that episode.

Selek
--
_____________________
Visit my Webpages:
Sa/Am Pictures and Links: http://members.shaw.ca/selek/
Sa/Am Story Archive: http://members.shaw.ca/pat_w/
Sa/Am Picture Gallery: http://members.shaw.ca/jo_pat/
Ambassador Soval: http://members.shaw.ca/soval/index.html
Vulcan Dictionary: http://www.starbase-10.de/vld/
Stekev
2005-06-01 18:10:14 UTC
Permalink
Post by Selek
|
| This was the final episode of Enterprise. It's more a TNG episode,
| than an ENT episode. Being broadcast back-to-back with "Terra Prime"
| made the contrast between the two episodes a bit... jarring.
As far as I am concerned, Terra Prime was the last episode of
Enterprise.
The other was merely a TNG episode that had nothing to do with
Enterprise
whatsoever. I was very disappointed in that episode.
I was also very disappointed, and don't consider it to have anything to
do with TNG either.

- Stekev


-----------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from the Vulcan-L list, send an email message
of "unsubscribe vulcan-l" to Vulcan-L-Request at shikahrsoho.com

Loading...